Crafting Legacy: The Six Pillars of Family Foundation Succes
The Establishment of Successful Family Foundations: Six Fundamental Principles
Introduction
In recent years, Europe has witnessed a significant growth in family foundations, reflecting a broader global trend towards structured philanthropy. While precise data on family foundations in Europe is more limited compared to the United States, several studies and reports indicate a robust and evolving landscape.
According to the European Foundation Centre (EFC), there are an estimated 147,000 public benefit foundations in Europe, with a significant portion being family foundations [1]. Countries such as Germany, Italy, and the United Kingdom have seen particularly strong growth in this sector. For instance, the Association of German Foundations reports that there are over 23,000 foundations in Germany, with family foundations forming a substantial subset [2].
In the United Kingdom, family foundations play a crucial role in the philanthropic sector. The Association of Charitable Foundations (ACF) notes that the top 300 family foundations in the UK gave £2.7 billion in 2018/19, accounting for 8% of all private giving in the UK [3]. Moreover, a study by Cass Business School found that nearly 60% of these foundations were established after 1980, indicating a relatively recent surge in family philanthropy [4].
This trend is not limited to Western Europe. In countries like Poland and Russia, the fall of communism in the late 20th century has led to a resurgence of private wealth and, consequently, an increase in family foundations. The European Research Network on Philanthropy (ERNOP) highlights that Eastern European countries are experiencing rapid growth in the philanthropic sector, with family foundations playing an increasingly important role [5].
The motivations behind this growth are multifaceted. Many European families associated with successful enterprises are establishing foundations as a means to manage their philanthropic activities and create a lasting legacy. As these families progress through generations, they often engage in key developmental exercises, including the formulation of a family constitution, the establishment of a family council, and the formalisation of philanthropic practices through the creation of a family foundation.
Research conducted by the European Venture Philanthropy Association (EVPA) indicates that while older family foundations in Europe tend to focus on traditional areas such as education and healthcare, newer foundations are increasingly addressing contemporary issues like climate change, social inequality, and technological innovation [6]. This shift reflects a growing awareness of global challenges and a desire to make a meaningful impact beyond local communities.
As the landscape of European family philanthropy continues to evolve, it becomes increasingly important to understand the principles that underpin successful family foundations. Drawing from best practices across Europe and beyond, we have identified six fundamental principles crucial to the development and longevity of family foundations. These principles, which we will explore in detail, provide a framework for families seeking to establish or refine their philanthropic endeavours in a manner that is both impactful and sustainable.
1. Establish the Foundation's Mission
As with other family institutions, the mission—or raison d'être—is paramount in providing guidance for philanthropic work across future generations. When establishing a family foundation, one must consider the following questions:
Is the foundation's primary purpose the successful investment and stewardship of assets to facilitate family philanthropy?
Does it exist to evaluate and disburse funds to qualified applicants?
Is its primary function to further specific family legacy projects or institutions (such as a school or hospital), or is funding open to a variety of requests?
Is it conceived as a family foundation serving to advance the family's specific philanthropic efforts, or as a non-family foundation whose principal function is to impartially receive and evaluate a multitude of requests before reaching decisions on support or rejection?
2. Determine the Foundation's Vision
The foundation's vision represents the future that the family aspires to create through the establishment of their family foundation—both in terms of community impact and family engagement. This vision serves to determine the focus and boundaries of giving. Consider the following:
What are the foundation's annual objectives?
How will future generations interact with the foundation?
How does the vision align with that which the family has identified for itself and its members?
How does it correspond with the vision of the family business?
What is the intended lifespan of the foundation?
What types of gifts are to be supported (e.g., capital campaigns, operating budgets, matching gifts, new programmes)?
3. Outline Foundation Governance Structures
It is prudent to approach the governance of the foundation with the same rigour one would apply to a business, encompassing accountability, role clarity, and comprehensive policies. The foundation administrator will benefit from a detailed job description and unfettered access to external advisors, particularly accountants, to ensure that giving amounts comply with legal requirements and align with the foundation's vision. Key considerations include:
Who will oversee the foundation's operations and disbursement process?
Will governance be entrusted to an independent group or family members?
Will a single individual be designated to manage foundation funds, field requests, determine appropriate fit and eligibility, and ultimately distribute funds?
Will the foundation operate as a natural extension of the family and business, or function independently of family involvement? (This will likely be determined by whether the foundation's purpose/mission is to serve the goals and objectives of the family or to support 'worthy causes' as they come to the foundation's attention.)
4. Formulate a Robust Distribution Strategy
A well-crafted distribution strategy is essential for the effective operation of a family foundation. Consider the following points when developing your approach:
Autonomy of distribution: Determine whether the foundation will operate solely as an independent entity or if a portion of funds will be allocated to individual family members for discretionary philanthropic use.
Scope of giving: Establish clear parameters for the types of causes and organisations eligible for support, ensuring alignment with the foundation's mission and vision.
Geographic focus: Decide whether to concentrate on local community needs or to extend support to national or international causes.
Evaluation criteria: Develop a comprehensive set of criteria for assessing funding requests, including metrics for measuring impact and success.
5. Construct a Robust Governance Framework
The establishment of a strong governance structure is crucial for the longevity and efficacy of a family foundation. Key considerations include:
Board composition: Determine the balance between family and non-family directors, considering the benefits of diverse perspectives and expertise.
Selection process: Establish transparent procedures for the nomination, election, and retirement of board members.
Term limits: Consider implementing term limits to ensure fresh insights and prevent stagnation.
Compensation policy: Carefully weigh the implications of director remuneration and expense reimbursement on the foundation's charitable capacity.
Generational transition: Develop a clear strategy for integrating younger family members into the foundation's governance over time.
6. Foster Meaningful Family Engagement
Cultivating active family involvement is vital for the foundation's continuity and the perpetuation of philanthropic values. Consider these approaches:
Educational initiatives: Develop programmes to educate younger generations about philanthropy, financial management, and social responsibility.
Junior board: Establish a junior board with limited decision-making power to provide hands-on experience for younger family members.
Rotating participation: Implement a system of rotating family involvement to ensure broad participation across different branches of the family.
Mentorship programmes: Create opportunities for experienced board members to mentor younger family members interested in philanthropy.
Family philanthropy days: Organise annual events where family members can collectively engage in charitable activities, fostering a shared sense of purpose.
Conclusion
The establishment of a family foundation presents a unique opportunity for families to create a lasting legacy of positive social impact. By carefully considering these six fundamental principles—mission, vision, governance, distribution, board structure, and family engagement—families can lay the groundwork for a philanthropic entity that not only serves the community but also strengthens familial bonds across generations.
A well-structured family foundation can serve as a powerful mechanism for instilling values of social responsibility and community service in future generations. It provides a platform for family members to work together towards shared goals, fostering unity and purpose beyond the confines of the family business.
However, it is crucial to approach this endeavour with the same level of rigour and strategic thinking one would apply to a business venture. Regular review and adaptation of the foundation's strategies and structures will ensure its continued relevance and effectiveness in an ever-changing social landscape.
Ultimately, the creation of a successful family foundation is a journey that requires dedication, thoughtful planning, and a genuine commitment to making a difference. When executed effectively, it can become a source of profound satisfaction and a testament to the family's values and aspirations for generations to come.
If you need help, don´t hesitate to contact us !
